The Tithing Controversy

This article is closed for comments.

Read Comments Comments (87)

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    YOUR BIG GRAMMAR HAS NOT BROUGHT ANY CHANGE TO YOUR COUNTRY, GET LOST WITH IMMEDIATE EFFECT THOMAS DICKENS!

  • shey-Gelege 11 years ago

    It is wonderful how even prison doors are opened for those who have imprisoned their own conscience out of ignorance to ran to freedom and yet they still keep sitting in jail saying to themselves 'we don't want to take this d ...
    read full comment

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    YOU CAN CALL ME A PRISONER, GREAT!!! A PRISONER OF THE GOSPEL AS PAUL WAS, HOWEVER I REFUSE TO BE A PRISONER OF MY OWN WISDOM AS YOU ARE. THE WISDOM OF GOD IS GREATER. NOBODY FORCES ME TO PAY TITHE I DO IT WILLINGLY. NOBODY F ...
    read full comment

  • Tunkumaruu 11 years ago

    It is obvious you are a receiver and not a Giver of tithes. You and your ilk live and flourish on our sweat.

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    THANX FOR YOUR COMMENT. I DO HAVE A JOB I GO TO MONDAY- SATURDAY. HOWEVER I CHOOSE TO BELIEVE WHAT THE SCRIPTURES SAY AND NOT WHAT YOU LOT ANTI -CHRISTS ARE SAYING

  • Sir Jay 11 years ago

    IN FACT, I DO NOT THINK PEOPLE WHO BELIEVE THAT THEY ARE FOLLOWING GOD'S DICTATES WHEN EVIDENCE ABOUND CLEARLY THAT WHAT THEY DO IS IN DIRECT CONTRAVENTION WITH WHAT GOD SAY CAN INHERIT THE KINGDOM OF GOD. HOW CAN GOD ADMIT F ...
    read full comment

  • Alex Inkoom, Japan 11 years ago

    TITHER does not pay tithe. He is a pastor who takes tithe from the poor to live big. He does not pay tithe. He is a sakawa 419 pastor. He is an armed robber in the church.

    We take tro tro to church and he drives a BMW with ...
    read full comment

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    FROM WHENCE DO YOU KNOW MW TO CALL ME A SAKAWA PASTOR? I M NOT A PASTOR, I DO NOT KNOW WHAT SAKAWA IS, MAYBE YOU CAN TELL ME MORE ABOUT IT. THE REAL ARMED ROBBER IS DECLARED IN MALACHI 3 :8 "Will a man rob God? Yet ye have ro ...
    read full comment

  • Alex Inkoom, Japan 11 years ago

    Deuteronomy 14:28-29
    New International Version (NIV)

    28 At the end of every three years, bring all the tithes of that year’s produce and store it in your towns, 29 so that the Levites (who have no allotment or inheritan ...
    read full comment

  • Ikemens 11 years ago

    I wonder how people accuses the very person who stands against mass disobedience to God. I don't know anything about the author of this article but I discovered by his writings that he is not a Christian. That is why he could ...
    read full comment

  • Asterix 11 years ago

    Talking about sheep, how do you take a tenth of 9 sheep? Does that mean you have to kill one and take part of the carcass to the temple? Please educate me?

  • Rev Dr Asamuah Tachie, Chicago 11 years ago

    Talking about sheep, how do you take a tenth of 9 sheep? Does that mean you have to kill one and take part of the carcass to the temple? Please educate me?

    THE NINTH SHEEP OR COW WAS NOT TITHED. THIS WAS GOD'S WAY OF PREVE ...
    read full comment

  • Asterix 11 years ago

    Thanks Rev. for your explanation.

  • Ikemens 11 years ago

    Convert one sheep into money and take 90% of the money to be your tithe. As simple as that.

  • Rev Dr Asamuah Tachie, Chicago 11 years ago

    Convert one sheep into money and take 90% of the money to be your tithe. As simple as that.

    THAT WAS NOT THE LAW OF GOD. THE POOR DID NOT PAY TITHE. SO IF YOU HAVE LESS THAN 10 SHEEP, YOU WERE NOT TITHES. ALSO, MONEY WAS N ...
    read full comment

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    NOW I KNOW WHY YOU WILL NOT MAKE IT TO HEAVEN, BY YOUR OWN ADMISSION GOD WILL NOT ALLOW FOOLS INTO HIS KINGDOM.
    WHO ARE U TO DETERMINE WHO ENTERS THE KINGDOM OR NOT? HOW MANY SOULS HAVE U SAVED THIS YEAR 2013?

  • Sammy Okoe 11 years ago

    jJESUS SAID IF U DO IT TO THE POOR YOU HAVE DONE IN FOR ME. IF YOU GIVE TO THE POOR, YOU HAVE GIVEN TO GOD. SO THE BIBLE SAYS.

    NOOOOOO! THE GREEDY PASTORS DONT WANT THAT. THEY WANT THE MONEY IN THEIR BANK ACCOUNT. THEY DON ...
    read full comment

  • Elder Adjei 11 years ago

    TITHES WAS TO BE EATEN

    Tithes--DEUT 14:22-27
    22 Be sure to set aside a tenth of all that your fields produce each year. 23 Eat the tithe of your grain, new wine and olive oil, and the firstborn of your herds and flocks in ...
    read full comment

  • Sir Jay 11 years ago

    CHRIST HIMSELF NEVER PAID TITHE, PAUL NEVER DID, NEITHER DID PERTER NOR ANY OF THE DISCIPLES. SO HOW COULD YOU BE A PRISONER OF CHRIST WE NEVER APPROVES OF WHAT YOU DO?
    YOU MAY BE A PRISONER OF SOMETHING OTHER THAN CHRIST. C ...
    read full comment

  • Sir Jay 11 years ago

    CHRIST HIMSELF NEVER PAID TITHE, PAUL NEVER DID, NEITHER DID PETER NOR ANY OF THE DISCIPLES. SO HOW COULD YOU BE A PRISONER OF CHRIST WHO NEVER APPROVES OF WHAT YOU DO?
    YOU MAY BE A PRISONER OF SOMETHING OTHER THAN CHRIST. C ...
    read full comment

  • Alex Inkoom, Japan 11 years ago

    JESUS AND HIS APOSTLES DID NOT PAY TITHES, NEITHER DID THEY ACCEPT TITHES. THE PHARISEES AND OTHER JEWS DID. BUT THEY WERE NOT CHRISTIANS, THEY FOLLOWED THE LAW.

    TITHES WAS PAID IN ONLY FARM ANIMALS AND FOODSTUFF. CARPENT ...
    read full comment

  • oyibaba 11 years ago

    Alex, tithing was never a problem for the Christian Jew. He paid it without questioning its significance in the New Covenant.

    The fact that tithing like The Sabbath Commandment has undergone so many abuses in the past does ...
    read full comment

  • Rev Dr Asamuah Tachie, Chicago 11 years ago

    TITHES WAS TO BE EATEN

    Tithes--DEUT 14:22-27
    22 Be sure to set aside a tenth of all that your fields produce each year. 23 Eat the tithe of your grain, new wine and olive oil, and the firstborn of your herds and flocks ...
    read full comment

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    Don't I have the right to do what I want with my own money? Or are you envious because I am generous?' MATTHEW 20:15

  • Tunkumaruu 11 years ago

    So that is how your biblical support for tithing ends. The evidence against tithing is overwhelming. We all have the right to do what we want with our money but we do not want others to deceive us to part with our money.That ...
    read full comment

  • Asterix 11 years ago

    Ha ha haa, thanks for your comment my brother. At last he is quoting from the bible to tell us that he has the right to do whatever he wants with his money!!!!!! That is very interesting. Why then does he want to tell us that ...
    read full comment

  • Pastor Amu, USA 11 years ago

    Tithing is robbing and stealing from god's people !
    .................................




    This is the second and hopefully the concluding part of our discussion on tithing. And let me begin by saying that this article i ...
    read full comment

  • Ikemens 11 years ago

    Well said!! I believe people like you shall never be out of God's favor. Keep the faith alive. I confidently believe that the old serpent can lay astray most especially the very elite who have been deceived to believe that th ...
    read full comment

  • Borntoshine 9 years ago

    It's only a fool who refuse to change his mind after having an encounter with the truth. truly how can God admit fools into His kingdom when He provided them with His word, but chose to adhere to the so call "pastors" who ama ...
    read full comment

  • Pastor Amu, USA 11 years ago

    ARE PASTORS TOADAY LEVITES?
    .......................................
    SOME SAY THAT SINCE PASTORS DO NOT WORK AND DEDICATE THEMSELVES TO THE SERVICE OF THE LORD, THEY ARE THE LEVITES OF TODAY AND MUST BENEFIT FROM TITHES.
    TH ...
    read full comment

  • Elder Adjei 11 years ago

    IF THE POOR, WIDOWS AND ORPHANS ARE THE ONES TO RECEIVE THE TITHES WHY ARE WE GIVING TITHES TO DUNCAN-WILLIAMS, MENSA-OTABIL AND OTHER RICH PASTORS.
    THESE PASTORS OWN PROPERTIES AND HAVE A LOT OF MONEY. GOD DOES NOT WANT US ...
    read full comment

  • *** 11 years ago

    Your likes and their incessant criticisms of GOD'S BLESSINGS TO HIS Servants,triggers HIS BLESSINGS the more.As an Elder,what have you SACRIFICED to propagate the Gospel to merit what you are criticizing???REPENT NOW!!!

  • Rev Dr Asamuah Tachie, Chicago 11 years ago

    OTABIL'S WEALTH DID NOT COME FROM GOD. IT COMES FROM STEALING AND MANIPILATION AND LIES. IT IS BETTER TO BE AN HONEST POOR CHRISTIAN, THAN A CROOKED FILTHY RICH 'CHRISTIAN'. READ BELOW GOD'S PURPOSE FOR TITHE.

    TITHES WAS ...
    read full comment

  • princewilly@ymail.com 11 years ago

    One Sunday a pastor told his congregation that the church needed some extra money and asked the people to prayerfully consider giving a little extra in the offering plate. He said that whoever gave the most would be able to p ...
    read full comment

  • Goodman 11 years ago

    thank you for this write up. this whole tithe issue, i dont quite get it because i remeber those days i have never heard the Presbyterians, Catholic, Methodise and those orthordose churches preaching about tithe. just recentl ...
    read full comment

  • Li 11 years ago

    No non-levite pastor qualifies to accept tithe from Christians.

  • Oko Kokuvi Anidu 11 years ago

    My success in business I put down to tithing.

  • Tithaborne 11 years ago

    We know, but Bill Gate and others give arms and not tithe.

  • Great man 11 years ago

    hahahaha…don't say what you don't know

  • Pastor Amu, USA 11 years ago

    Who will feed the pastors?

    JESUS AND HIS APOSTLES DID NOT TAKE TITHES FROM ANYONE. HOW DD THEY EAT? THEY LIVED ALRIGHT AND SPREAD THE GOSPEL. THEY LIVED SIMPLE AND HUMBLE LIVES. THEY DID NOT NEED ANY TITHES. ACTUALLY, THEY ...
    read full comment

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    HOW MANY SOULS HAVE U SAVED IN 2013 PASTOR?

  • Rev Dr Asamuah Tachie, Chicago 11 years ago

    TITHES WAS TO BE EATEN BY THE POOR

    Tithes--DEUT 14:22-27
    22 Be sure to set aside a tenth of all that your fields produce each year. 23 Eat the tithe of your grain, new wine and olive oil, and the firstborn of your herds ...
    read full comment

  • Asona Ba 11 years ago

    THOMAS REMEMBER GOD DOES NOT FORCE ANYONE TO GIVE HIM TITHES.IF YOU UNDERSTAND OR LOVE GOD YOU WILL ALWAYS OBEY HIS WORD.THE BIBLE SAYS BRING YE ALL THE TITHES INTO THE STOREHOUSE THAT THERE MAY BE MEAT IN MY HOUSE.AS IN ALL ...
    read full comment

  • Tithaborne 11 years ago

    Just look at someone with a myopic mind. Please read and understand the Bible and stop these arguement. The writer is not saying don't give, but wise-up and know that the tithes you are paying is just enriching a few people's ...
    read full comment

  • yao 11 years ago

    or are you saying that duncan williams is and other fake prophets are Gods? they only take take your money to spend to spend it on themselves, period.

  • Tithaborne 11 years ago

    Pastors have already brainwashed people, using curses and gimmicks on their congregants and no amount of advice will change their mind. But in essence these pastors are just enriching themselves with houses, cars and living a ...
    read full comment

  • KK 11 years ago

    People have been brainwashed...

  • Tetteh Sowah 11 years ago

    i was one of the brainwashe people. i have paid tithe faithfuly for the past 23 yrs without searching what the Bible says. I only read Malachi 3-10. I just got the book by bro Amartey on tithing. i read all the bible verses i ...
    read full comment

  • GEORGE ESHUN, USA 11 years ago

    Dont be too sure of how brother Amartey has interpreted God's words about tithes. Remember the JEWS, the costodians of the tithe system are still in existance and iam telling you from experince they are fabulously blessed bec ...
    read full comment

  • Kwesi Ampah, Germany 11 years ago

    . Remember the JEWS, the costodians of the tithe system are still in existance and iam telling you from experince they are fabulously blessed because they are obedient to God's commands including tithing.

    YOU OBVIOUSLY KNO ...
    read full comment

  • Francis 11 years ago

    Thanks for the insight

  • gandalf 11 years ago

    I think the so called tithing controversy is a devilish attempt to rob faithful tithers of their covenant rewards. Please stick to the WORD and not high sounding intellectualism.

  • kk 11 years ago

    Tithing any thing bibilical Ghanaians will go down,that is our weakness.
    Pastors are rich even to the extend of owning their own church and the poor continue to be poor.
    God bless the writer..this is good info...

  • Oko Kokuvi Anidu 11 years ago

    In the orthodox church tithe will never go to the Pastor. May the problem has to do with the charismatic churches where all is about the Pastor

  • RAPH 11 years ago

    PLS IN GERMANY I AM TOLD TITHE IS DEDUCTED FROM SALARIES DIRECT WHEN YOU BELONG TO THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH. THIS IS NOT GHANAIAN MATTER BUT OF FAITH. YOUR FAITH SHALL GUIDE YOU TO GIVE OR NOT TO GIVE.

  • Sir Jay 11 years ago

    PEOPLE PAY CHURCH TAX IN GERMANY AND NOT TITHES AS YOU MAY THINK. KNOW THAT EVEN IN ISRAEL WHERE THE LEVITES LIVE. IN TODAY'S WORLD NOBODY PAY TITHE IN ISRAEL BECAUSE RABBIS ARE PAID AND THE TEMPLE WHERE THE STORE HOUSE WAS L ...
    read full comment

  • TITHER 11 years ago

    THE TEMPLE WILL BE REBUILT ACCORDING TO BIBLE PROPHECY! NEVER SAY "NEVER REBUILT"

  • Nana Yaw 11 years ago

    THE TEMPLE WILL BE REBUILT ACCORDING TO BIBLE PROPHECY! NEVER SAY "NEVER REBUILT"

    I have read some posts calling you TITHER a sakawa pastor. I believe you are one. where is your Bible knowledge? You are a greedy pastor lik ...
    read full comment

  • L. D 11 years ago

    THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR T DICKENS FOR THIS INSIGHT. I NEVER HEAR PASTORS TALK ABOUT TITHES AND MAKE REFERENCE TO DEUT 14:22-29. THEY ALWAYS TALK ABOUT MALACHI3:10. LOOKING AT THE WAY MOST PASTORS HAVE ENRICHED THEMSELVES BY TA ...
    read full comment

  • Konoreyawa 11 years ago

    I will never give any church money to be used by so called Pastor to build their home and buy expensive when their congregation take tro tro to church service. This is just wrong in my eyes. This si what is happening in churc ...
    read full comment

  • Agyaaku 11 years ago

    Who is this Thomas Dickens? Please read the entire Bible and you will be better informed. I think you are simply being too simplistic with your knowledge of the scriptures. Faithful Christians should know the blessings in pay ...
    read full comment

  • Obiba Kwame 11 years ago

    Faithful christians should follow the teachings of Christ. Did Christ mention anywhere in the New Testament that you should tithe your pastor? Rather Christ taught his followers to give to the poor and needy. Now if youu thin ...
    read full comment

  • Micheal Kumi, JW- Medina 11 years ago

    Well, another food for thought. My biggest worry is the educated pastors who call for tenth of ones annual worth, which are paid monthly, and also call for several daily, weekly, monthly, developmental, pastor's transfer, and ...
    read full comment

  • Pastor Sam 11 years ago

    I GOT MY COPY LAST WEEK. IT IS A VERY GOOD BOOK. IT OPENED MY EYED TO A LOT OF TRUTH ABOUT TITHING. GREAT JOB BY A SERVANT OF GOD.

  • Musa Kano 11 years ago

    This article is just a rehash of Amartey's sophistry (faulty reasoning)!

    Please do not be swayed by its appeal. Note that the first sermon ever preached on earth was sophistic and it was delivered by the devil to one congr ...
    read full comment

  • Obiba Kwame 11 years ago

    Your long tratise proves nothing, absolutely nothing, and I am apalled at you shallow attempts at justifying this nonsense of tithing.

    You must be one of those people using the bible to scam ignorant people of their hard-e ...
    read full comment

  • yao 11 years ago

    pharisees for paying tithes to pastors to pastors for them to live big. these greedy pastors con their followers to give them the tithes to lead influenza lifestyles.

  • Zuri 11 years ago

    The pastors & elders of the church of Pentecost should listen to this writer. They are milking members while they loan this money to themselves in doing business.Unfortunately, 90% of their members cannot read the Bible. The ...
    read full comment

  • GEORGE ESHUN, USA 11 years ago

    This tithe issue again? I tell you what, spiritual thinks are spiritually discerned. Those who faithfully give tithes has evidence of blessings in diverse forms in their lives, so no matter how tithining is critisized, people ...
    read full comment

  • Bam Buri Nyankpalla 11 years ago

    if all Ghanaians tithe to me, i will erect railway lines nationwide, build sea transpotation from Half Assini to Aflao, and 4-way lanes to interconnect all cities, towns and outposts in Ghana. if you tithe to me, i will creat ...
    read full comment

  • Benjamin owiredu 11 years ago

    Hebrew 7:5,12 says tithe law is change.anyone who takes it is a bible robber

  • Benjamin owiredu 11 years ago

    Hebrew 7:5,12 says tithe law is change.anyone who takes it is a bible robber

  • Ama 11 years ago

    It's important to support God's work. Find a genuine church project and support directly. Say church building by a village church. Otherwise it's Trassacco living for most pastors!!!

  • Mr. B 11 years ago

    Read Matthew 23:23. Jesus said to the tithe paying scribes and Pharisees that, "woe unto you". In other words, cursed be onto you. Jesus proposed a better alternative to the tithe, which is show mercy, justice and love to the ...
    read full comment

  • GAK 11 years ago

    Mr Dicken, I wonder if you're communicating to the ordinary? Please learn to talk to everybody the next time you're addressing the public. I largely agree with you though....in the last days the will be false prophets all ove ...
    read full comment

  • *** 11 years ago

    and ABSOLUTELY NOTHING is going to stop any faithful tither to relinquish the secret of its blessings to any bashing from any quaters."Beloved,l pray in all respects(WISH ABOVE ALL THINGS),that you may prosper and be in good ...
    read full comment

  • L. D 11 years ago

    READ THE BIBLE. GET KNOWLEDGE. DO NOT BE CHEATED.

  • *** 11 years ago

    STILL,IT WORKS!!!

  • TITHE PAYER 11 years ago

    I WILL FOREVER PAY MY TITHE, EVEN MORE THAN TENTH.

  • TITHER NO 2 11 years ago

    I don't care if tithe is biblical or not. I will always pay tithe. it is my own money. Pastor is spending my tithe on mansions and Armani suits but I don't care. I live a poor life, I cant pay my kids school fees but I will g ...
    read full comment

  • Ikemens 11 years ago

    You said it well but the Pastor is not your God. The pastor is the servant of your God.

  • L D 11 years ago

    Thank you very much Mr. T Dickens for this insight.
    I never hear pastors talk about tithes and make reference to Deut 14:22-29. They always talk about Malachi3:10. Looking at the way most pastors have enriched themselves by ...
    read full comment

  • *** 11 years ago

    If you desire to be perfect,"replied JESUS,"GO AND SELL ALL THAT YOU HAVE,AND GIVE TO THE POOR,AND YOU SHALL HAVE WEALTH(TREASURE)IN HEAVEN;AND COME,FOLLOW ME."(Matthew 19:21)This is the ONE THING lacking in your acquired kno ...
    read full comment

  • Rev Bonsu 11 years ago

    The love of money is the root of all evil. The bible says to eat the tithe. The bible says buy food with the money and take the food tot he temple. Do not take money to the temple.

    But the greedy money pastors swindle and ...
    read full comment

  • Brother Amartey 11 years ago

    https://www.facebook.com/tithingrobbingandstealingfromgodspeople

    https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/359816

  • Robert Munyui Kamunyu 9 years ago

    Tithing was under and is under the law with a curse for Christians seeking salvation under the law, Galatians 3:3-13, Malachi 3:1-18. When pastors and priests lie by quoting Malachi 3:1-18,under the law IN OLD COVENANT, how ...
    read full comment

  • Robert Munyui Kamunyu 8 years ago

    Tithing was under and is under the law with a curse for Christians seeking salvation under the law,Leviticus27:1-34,Malachi 3:1-18.When bishops, pastors, elders, and priests humbly teach falsehood by quoting tithes in Malach ...
    read full comment