The debate over the Black Stars’ goalkeeping crisis has taken a sharp turn as sports pundit Christopher Nimley raised concerns about the readiness of local favorite Benjamin Asare, calling instead for alternative talent to shore up Ghana’s goalkeeping department.

Speaking on the Jupay Podcast Live, Nimley offered a blunt assessment of the current options available to Otto-Addo, sparking a conversation about the gap between domestic football and the international stage.

While Benjamin Asare has earned plaudits for his performances in the Ghana Premier League, Coach Nimley argued that domestic statistics are misleading. He claimed that the "quality of finishing" in the local league is currently too poor to serve as a legitimate benchmark for an international goalkeeper.

"Benjamin Asare is not the best goalkeeper for the team," Nimley stated firmly. "The quality of finishing in our local league is not a good enough test."

Nimley explained that most of the threats Asare faces are "loose crosses and misdirected shots," which do not prepare a keeper for the clinical finishing seen at the World Cup or AFCON levels. He however admitted that had Benjamin Asare and the Black Stars played in the African Cup of Nations, he would have been better tested and thus a more confident choice. This did not happen and it makes Asare, in Nimley's opinion, a risky option.

In a move to bring confidence to the post, Coach Nimley urged the Ghana Football Association (GFA) to look toward the Eredivisie. He specifically named Rome-Jayden Owusu-Oduro, the highly-rated AZ Alkmaar goalkeeper who plays his club football in the top tier Dutch league, as the ideal candidate for the Black Stars.

Owusu-Oduro, has previously expressed interest in representing Ghana, and is seen by Nimley as the high-caliber alternative the team desperately needs. According to the coach, bringing in a player tested in a top-tier European league would provide the "new dimension" that Otto Addo’s technical team has so far failed to deliver.

The critique did not stop at local players. Nimley also took issue with current first-choice shot-stopper, Lawrence Ati-Zigi, echoing concerns about his inability to provide a "clean sheet" guarantee.

Nimley pointed to Ati-Zigi’s record at St. Gallen, noting that he continues to "leak goals" both at the club and international levels. "He is not good enough," Nimley remarked, suggesting that the Black Stars cannot continue to rely on a keeper who requires the attack to score three or four goals to secure a victory.

The consensus from the discussion was clear: the "heritage" and "refresh" promised by Otto Addo must move beyond rhetoric. For Coach Nimley, that starts with a ruthless overhaul of the goalkeeping department, prioritizing elite-level testing over local league form.

As the Black Stars face mounting pressure, the eyes of the nation remain on whether the technical team will heed the call to cap Owusu-Oduro or continue with the current rotation.