The multimillion-dollar negligence suit filed by Dram Oil and Trading Limited against auditing firm Deloitte and Touche is expected to resume in December at the Commercial Division of the High Court in Accra.
Dram Oil is seeking damages, alleging that Deloitte’s handling of a court-ordered audit produced a flawed report that caused the company substantial financial losses.
The action, filed in May 2022, includes a claim of US$187.596 million in alleged lost profits, alongside other financial claims, interest and damages.
The company is also seeking a declaration that Deloitte breached its duty of care in preparing the audit report.
The dispute originated from a petroleum transaction involving Dram Oil, Vihama Energy Limited and CalBank, which provided financing for the transaction.
Following a 2015 judgment, the court ordered an audit of Vihama’s records to establish payments and other funds due under the agreement between the parties. Deloitte was subsequently appointed to undertake the exercise.
Dram Oil contended that Deloitte’s final report departed from the findings underlying the audit order and instead concluded that the company owed Vihama money. The report was subsequently adopted by the court.
The company’s lawyers have also alleged that earlier drafts of the report showed a balance in Dram Oil’s favour, but the final version reversed that position without giving the company an opportunity to respond before it was filed.
Deloitte has disputed owing Dram Oil the duty of care alleged by the company.
Its lawyers have also challenged portions of the witness statement of Dram Oil’s first witness, arguing that they introduced matters not contained in the company’s pleadings. Dram Oil opposed the objections.
In earlier proceedings, Deloitte’s counsel, Mr Ace Anan Ankomah, maintained that the firm conducted the audit in accordance with the court’s directions, submitted its report and was cross-examined on its findings.
Vihama, which was joined to the negligence suit, also applied to have the action against it struck out, arguing that the issues had already been determined in previous proceedings.
Deloitte supported the application, while Dram Oil opposed it, maintaining that its allegations of negligence against the auditing firm had not been determined in the earlier case.
The High Court dismissed the application, holding that the contested issues were intertwined with factual questions that required examination at trial.
The ruling allowed the substantive negligence action to continue but did not determine whether Deloitte was negligent.









